The war in Ukraine is influencing how Taiwanese think about conflict

Full Text

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽ

ᝄԣሊӔː*

௓˙ඣ

؇юɽኪط݁ኪӻпଣ઺બ

ˮ҃ࢸ

ʫശ༺ɽኪז౶ၪ̋౶ʱط݁ࣧኪӻпଣ઺બ

ю؁ڿ

זڛیˋ৵ɽኪط݁ၾ͕ໆኪӻпଣ઺બ

໢ᘴʩ

໋ಷီ౶ɽኪ਷ყ޼Ӻၾ຅˾ႧԊኪӻ࿬ط݁ኪӻᑺࢭ઺બࡒӻ˴΂DOIj10.30390/ISC.202209_61(3).0004 145

* ຾൬Ը๕j͉޼Ӻٙ຾൬Ը๕މᐼ௅Зߕ׵਷ശସ཭तਜٙ౽ࢫΌଢၽᝄ޼Ӻʕː

Global Taiwan Institute˸ʿߕ਷;ɻ཭໋ಷီ౶ɽኪ਷ყ޼ӺʕːCenter for In-

ternational Studies, University of St. Thomasf

޼Ӻཫൗ̅j͉޼Ӻٙਪ՜׵ੂБۃʊ຾΋Бཫൗ̅d޼Ӻཀ೻ʕʔึϞһҷਪ՜e

һҷᅵ͉ᅰٙዚึfཫൗ̅ၣѧމEvidence in Governance and Politics (EGAP, http://

egap.org/, the project’s registration link is http://egap.org/content/psychology-self-defense-

and-self-determination) ձ Open Science Foundation (OSF, http://osf.io/, the project’s regis-

tration link is https://osf.io/6h7d8)f

146cਪᕚၾ޼Ӻcୋ61՜ୋ3ಂ

࿜ࠅ

ၽᝄ͏଺ІҢԣሊٙӔːd࿁׵Ң਷਷ԣʿ؇ԭਜਹձ̻ޫϞࠠɽᅂ

ᚤfˈՉ݊ίࠦ࿁̙ঐٙՇ֦ላرً߉ɨdə༆ၽᝄ͏଺ٙІҢԣሊจ

ᗴdၾ਷࢕τΌ޴ࢹࢹᗫf್ϾdνО༆ᙑၽᝄ͏଺ІҢԣሊӔːࢨٙ

ମdίତπٙ਷ყᗫڷ˖ᘠ༁ٙࠦীሞϞࠢfҢࡁႩމd͏଺ίଣࠇ׌ၑ

݊щᗴจਞ኷ࣛdཀ̘ٙ੽ࠏ຾᜕݊ːଣɪ௰ٜટ΃፠ٙ༟ৃdΪϤ੽ࠏ

຾᜕ٙλᕸdଣሞɪึᅂᚤ͏଺ٙІҢԣሊӔːf͉˖Ҫ੽ࠏ຾᜕ʱϓɧ

ࠦࡈΣd̍ࠏܼ၇eᙂ੻ࠏԫ৅ᇖ࿁ɪ኷ఙٙϞ͜೻ܓe˸ʿ੽ࣛࠏၾڗ

޴ٙ֜ஈرًdԨ׵2018ϋ7˜։ৄط݁ɽኪPollcracyLabੂБᅵ͉ᅰ1001

ٙၣ༩ਪ՜f୕ࠇഐ؈ᜑͪdၽᝄ͏଺؂Ҙࠏٙ၇˸ʿ൙Пաࠏԫ৅ᇖٙ

Ϟ͜೻ܓdே࿁ІҢԣሊӔːϞᜑഹᅂᚤࠏ၇˴ࠏ٤މࠅ༰৷dШၾ

޴֜ڗஈ຾᜕ۆӚϞᅂᚤf̤ɓ˙ࠦd൳ϋٙڗ˰˾d൳හΣ׵ᙂ੻຅ϋ

੽הࠏաٙ৅ᇖϞпࠏ׵ԫԣሊf͉˖ɰਗ਼ί௰ܝ౤̈਷࢕τΌ޴ᗫ݁ٙ

ഄܔᙄf

ᗫᒟ൚jτΌ޼Ӻe່ਕҘeࠏ͏ᗫڷe੽ࠏ຾᜕eІҢԣሊӔː

*cc*cc*

壹、前言

ᎇഹʕ਷ၾߕ਷ί؇ԭήਜ݁ٙഄ˸ʿැɢᔷᜊdՇ֦ᙄᕚίڐ఻ϋΎܓ

ϓމ਷ყᗫٙءೊᓃfίτΌ޼Ӻsecurity studies޴ٙᗫীሞ຅ʕdࡈ᜗

ᄴٙࠦীሞdˈՉ݊ၽᝄ͏଺࿁׵ІҢԣሊঐɢၾՉจᗴ޴ٙᗫ࿒ܓdɰ஗

εϣ౤ʿfІ2017ϋ˸Ըdίၽᝄߕ٫א਷ٙኪஔޢe౽ࢫeޟЇ਷ึᛓᗇ

ึ຅ʕd০࿁ၽᝄ͏଺࿁਷ԣၾЪ኷จᗴٙઞীһ੬ϓࠠމᓃ༑ᕚʘɓf1 ڐ

1 ԷνjH. R. McMaster and Matt Pottinger, “Cold War II{Just How Dangerous Is China?”

Hoover Institution, 2021/04/13fhttps://www.hoover.org/research/cold-war-ii-just-how-

dangerous-chinadݟቡࣛගj2021/06/26f

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽᝄԣሊӔːc147

ϋd຅ɛ͏༆ࠏٙࠏ׳ዚ᎖ᐿٙආɝၽᝄٙঘ٤ᗆйਜeޟЇ݊൳ཀऎࢠʕ

ᇞdһ׼ᆽᗇྼəՇ֦ʘගٙၡੵઋၫdɰᜫၽᝄ͏଺һ̋ᗫː࿁׵਷ԣၾЪ

኷จᗴ޴ٙᗫীሞf

ͦۃ࿁׵ၽᝄ͏଺ٙІҢԣሊจᗴ޴ᗫሜݟdяତ̈Ըٙഐ޴؈຅ʱ

؜fᑘԷԸႭd2017ϋϋֵӁдɽኪ։ৄط݁ɽኪੂБٙၽᝄ਷࢕τΌሜݟ

Taiwan National Security Surveyʕd༔ਪ͏଺ίՇ֦ΪၽዹϾˏ೯኷

نرًɨึਂޟჿdස23%̸̛ٙ͏଺ΫᏐᗴจٜટ੽ࠏe݊٫א˕݁ٙܵ

ִഃ͍ٜࠦટΫᏐࠏԫላٙ߉Ϋഈf2 Шίཞϋ2018d͟ၽᝄ͏˴ਿږึ

Νᅵ։ৄط݁ɽኪהੂБٙ͏จሜݟʕdۍϞ৷༺68%ٙၽᝄ͏଺ί஗ਪՑd

৿νʕ਷˸؛ɢ୕ɓၽᝄd݊щᗴจމၽᝄϾ኷ࣛdഗə֛ٙٵഈࣩf3

ˮ҃ࢸ2017዆ଣəڐϋԸኪஔ޼Ӻʕ࿁׵ၽᝄ͏଺݊щᗴจЪ኷ٙ͏จ

ሜݟdɰ೯ତ͏จሜݟഐ޴؈຅ήʱ؜i˕ܵЪ኷ٙˢԷ௰৷̙༺Ց82%d̈

ତί2015ϋ˰ޢᄆ࠽ᝈሜݟThe World Value Survey4dϾ˕ܓܵ௰Эۆٙ

ٙࠑۃ݊ၽᝄ਷࢕τΌሜݟf຅್dʔΝٙ͏จሜݟ͟׵ੂБ˙όeੂБࣛ

ගeɗЇ׵ਪᕚાޫࠑϞהʔΝdה˸ഐ؈̙ঐɽࢬࢰ޴f͏଺வᅵఊॱٙ

ίཥ༑אၣ༩ਪ՜ɪΫഈІʉ݊щᗴจ͂˽dՉྼʔɓ֛˾ڌ˼ࡁॆ͍ึவ

ᅵਂdˀϾ˼ٙࡁவ၇וፕһֻֻ஗ൖ݊މ຾᏶ኪ֛ה່ٙ٤ɹႭͣ༑

Cheap TalkFarrell and Rabin 1996f

ί͏ሜഐ؈ʱ؜e˲ε᙮৿ண׌ਪᕚرًٙɨdމОੂ݁א٫݁ഄᝈ࿀࢕

ʥცࠅίจၽᝄ͏଺ί͏จሜݟ༁ڌ༺̈ٙЪ኷จᗴճkୋɓdуԴҢ਷ʊ୞

˟əਗࡰบ඾ࣛಂᑗࣛૢಛdʔΎϞˀҸɽ௔ٙ͂ၑdШމəԣ˟ᅮɛආ

Ҹeၪᚐձ̻dίࠦ࿁̙ঐٙᅮࠏɝࣛڧdҢהࡁՓٙࠈ੶ʷ਷ԣၾԣሊঐɢ

޴ᗫ݁ഄdԷνႴሥഄଫPorcupine Strategyเ˻ᆀ 2009d5 ɰఱ݊ί

2 ༟ࣘԸ๕jhttps://sites.duke.edu/pass/data/fݟቡࣛගj2019/03/15f

3 “Taiwanese people willing to fight for democracy: surveys.” Focus Taiwanfhttp://focustai-

wan.tw/news/aipl/201804190036.aspxdݟቡࣛගj2019/03/15f

4 ༟ࣘԸ๕jhttps://srda.sinica.edu.tw/datasearch_detail.php?id=1220dݟቡࣛගj

2019/03/18f

5 הፗႴሥഄଫ݊ᗫ׵ԣሊഄଫ፯኿ٙীሞdϞሞܸ٫̈dၽᝄίᏐ࿁̙ঐٙɝࣛڧd

Ꮠમ͜࿁ࠏࠅࠠ͏ண݄ආБଯ౳e৽ༀe௪΅dภৣਖ਼ุʷٙ௔ࠏԸᏘৗᅮɛdɰ

148cਪᕚၾ޼Ӻcୋ61՜ୋ3ಂ

ᅮɛ೮௔Ъ኷رًٙɨdҢ˙ࠏ͏ΥɢආБଯ౳e৽ༀeڭπྼɢdΎภৣਖ਼

ุ௔ࠏʚ˸ˀᏘdவᅵٙഄଫʥცࠅ͏จٙ˕ܵ˸ʿΌ͏ৣΥfୋɚdމəੂ

Бவᅵٙ੶ʷ਷ԣഄଫdҢ਷ৰəڭϞڐ20ຬ੬௪ࠏɛ˸̮dһϞܝ௪ࠏɛߒ

230ຬɛெኮᙒ 2019fίҢ਷ɽεᅰӲɿʥϞ຅жˈՉ່݊ਕҘٙ຾

᜕ٙઋرɨd͏଺࿁׵਷ԣ˸ʿ࿁׵኷ج޶ٙنdІ್ึீཀ͏˴Փܓᔷᜊމ

͏จdආϾᅂᚤҢ਷ٙ਷ԣ݁ഄԷjਞϽ؍ዣп2010ٙীሞfୋɧdΪ

Ϥd຅ኪஔ޼Ӻ࿁׵͏଺࿁׵਷ԣၾ኷ج޶ٙنdҬՑ޴ᗫٙ༆ᙑΪ९ܝdఱ

Ϟ̙ঐආɓӉீཀ܁ෂ݁אഄપਗٙ˙όԸҷᜊ͏଺࿁׵਷ԣၾ኷ج޶ٙنd

੶ʷၽᝄ͏଺ٙІሊӔːdί኷ࣛఱϞ̙ঐһ̋ৣΥִ݁˸ʿࠏඟٙБਗdί

ྠഐɓرًٙߧɨdආɓӉϞתٙࣖҤʕ਷؛ɢ͕ၽٙБމd˸ၪᚐၽऎٙձ

̻f

ɰఱ݊Ⴍd໊଺ٙІҢԣሊจᗴ࿁ၽᝄԸႭᆽྼࠅࠠܘdΪމึᅂᚤՑҢ

ٙࡁ਷ԣ݁ഄʿՉྼБϓࣖd್Ͼd༈ܣჿᅵ༆ᙑɓছ͏଺ࡈٙɛԣሊจᗴ৷

ЭճkІ1958ϋٙɞɚɧޏ኷˸ԸdΪމၽᝄ͏଺ഒɽεᅰʊ຾ӚϞྼყਞ

ၾא຾ዝཀ኷نdϾ΢ॴ່ਕ઺ԃʕ࿁׵኷ٙنྼყرً͵ഹኈʔεd਷৷ʕ

ࠏٙ৅ሙ೻ɰڢ৷ʕאɽኪٙɝኪϽ༊ධͦdה˸͏଺ԨӚϞ˴ਗጐ฽ኪ୦኷

޴نᗫٝᗆٙਗዚf6 ΪϤၽᝄ͏଺࿁׵኷ٝٙنᗆၾ຾᜕d̙ঐɽεԸІ׵

຅жהኪdאගટᛓၲಀ؂жҘٙ٫຾᜕ʱԮf౬Ԋʘdၽᝄ͏଺ίːʕࠇၑ

݊щᗴจ͂˽ࣛdː༁ٙଣࠇ׌ၑᅺ๟Ꮠ༈ၾ຅жٙࣛ຾᜕ึϞהᗫஹfΪ

Ϥd͉˖޼ٙӺ˙Σί׵ઞীၽᝄ͏଺ٙ຅ж຾᜕݊щᅂᚤ࿁׵኷ࣛنЪ኷ٙ

จᗴd˸ʿՉᅂᚤٙᅼόf

Ң਷ͦۃኪஔٙޢτΌ޼Ӻ຅ʕd࿁ࠏ׵ඟၾ޴ٙط݁ᗫ޼Ӻɽεණʕ

׵ɧᗳfୋɓᗳ݊ீཀ΢၇޼Ӻ˙جઞীᅄжՓၾ෍жՓٙᎴॹᓃ݄͍ቜ

ఱ݊ႭცࠅΌ͏ɓৎৣΥdίऎࠏၾࠏ٤ɰೌڜج˟ᅮɛرًٙɨdආБˀᏘf޴

ᗫীሞ̙Ԉ຾᏶ኪɛٙவᇐజኬj“China’s Might is Forcing Taiwan to Rethink its

Military Strategy.”fhttps://www.economist.com/asia/2019/01/26/chinas-might-is-forcing-

taiwan-to-rethink-its-military-strategydݟቡࣛගj2019/03/15f

6 ίٟึʷཀ೻຅ʕdࡈɛ௰ɽٙኪ୦ࠏԫ޴ᗫٝᗆਗዚd̙ঐ݊ԸІ׵ɽኪࠏ৅ሙ೻

תеҘಂٙ஝֛d̙ঐึԴ௅ʱɽኪ͛˴ਗࡌ୦਷ԣሙ೻fชᑽਛΤᄲݟɛ౤̈

ٙীሞf

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽᝄԣሊӔːc149

2002; ᇸʑ፯ 2010dୋɚᗳ݊ۆઞীҢ਷͏˴ʷٙཀ೻ʕࠏඟၾִ݁ʘගٙ

ᗫڷe˸ʿ˖ɛჯ޴ٙࠏᗫᅂᚤ௓׼ڲ 2005dୋɧᗳڐ݊ۆϋԸණʕઞ

ীқᗴҘࠏɛၾٙ֜ࠏवᐄeʺቋeם෍eɗЇࡐ׵ଣ࿒ܓഃ޴ᗫБމᄎ΀

ॉഃ 2010; ௓֚׹ 2016fۃՇᗳٙ˖ᘠ͟޼׵Ӻ˙Σცࠅdɽεණʕ׵˖

͉ʱؓ˸ʿஞሔجfᒱ್ୋɧᗳٙ˖ᘠ຾੬Դ͜ਪ՜ሜݟЪ޼މӺ˙όdШ͟

޼׵Ӻਪᕚၾணࠢڻٙࠇdɽεᅰٙਪ՜සණʕίତҘࠏɛ֜ࠏאɪdϾӚϞ

ᓒɽՑܝ௪ɛɗЇ׵Ό᜗਷͏f7

኷نၾࠏԫ˓ݬ͉Ԓ݊฽ՉልᕏٙБމd͏଺ίܠϽ݊щࠅ̋ɝІҢԣሊ

ٙБਗԸࠦ࿁̮Ըࠏԫ۾উࡉࣛٙdఱၑʔՈ௪ਖ਼ุٝ؛ࠏٙᗆd௰ৎᇁɰঐ

੄༶͜ɓԬ໘ʕ̙ঐϞٙઠܠheuristicԸᏍпࠇၑfϾίၽᝄٟٙึၾ݁

຾এഖɨdӊࡈ਷͏؂жҘٙࣛ຾᜕ၾהኪdΥଣપ಻у݊ӊࡈɛ௰̙ঐኽ˸

кᓙ˕ܵІҢԣሊٙઠܠdΪϤdˢ༰աཀжҘ͏଺Չ຾᜕࿁׵ІҢԣሊٙ࿒

ܓdίၽᝄݖ࣪ٙʘɨd࿁׵ІҢԣሊ޴ٙᗫ޼ӺԸႭdɰ݊ɓࡈ௰Ϟࣖଟ˸

ʿӻ୕ٙ׌˙جʘɓf͉˖ٙͦᅺdఱ݊Ҏૐ੽աஞ٫൙Пཀ̘ԟݬ຅ж຾᜕

ʕdҬՑᅂᚤ˕ܵІҢԣሊٙᗫᒟΪ९f

ࠠᓃί׵dͦܘۃˇϞτΌ޼Ӻ޴ٙᗫЪۜਖ਼ژীሞᅂᚤၽᝄɛ͏ІҢԣ

ሊจᗴ৷ЭٙΪ९dͦۃ০࿁ၽᝄٙ኷ن˕٫אܵІҢԣሊจᗴٙীሞd̥Ϟ

Ԉ׵Yeh and Wu2021f˼ࡁ೯ତdᅂᚤІҢԣሊจᗴٙ఻ࡈΪ९ܼ̍j܁

̺ዹͭ݊щึˏ೯኷ٙنႩٝe࿁ߕ਷ʧɝၽऎ኷ٙن̙ঐ׌Ⴉٝe਷ૄႩ

Νeၾʕ਷ٙАᇝஹഐe݁ᙣႩΝe઺ԃ˥̻d˸ʿ݊щ຾ዝཀ኷ٙن຾᜕d

್ϾYeh and Wu2021ԨӚϞ࿁ࠏ׵၇ٙᙄᕚ࿁׵ၽᝄ͏଺ІҢԣሊج޶ٙ

ආБଉɝٙীሞdҢࡁҎૐ̙˸໾੶வࡈ˙ٙࠦʔԑdආБઞ॰ό޼ٙӺԸী

ሞ຅ж຾᜕˸ʿࠏ၇νОᅂᚤɛࡁ࿁ࠏ׵ԫԣሊᙄᕚج޶ٙdԨ౤Զһεྼᗇ

ɪٙᇞ॰f

7 അ٫ҬՑٙਬɓԷ̮؍މԃͮ2017޼ٙӺdவᇐ˖௝Νࣛீཀਪ՜ሜݟ਷͏˸ʿ

ତҘࠏɛ࿁׵ʕ΍۾ࠥ٤উج޶ٙfШϤ޼Ӻٙਪ՜˙ό݊ீཀᑕࣣ൨˖ᅄӋ෬ਪ՜

٫dϾ˲35๋˸ɨٙաஞ٫̕ə82%dΪϤ̙ঐึϞ˾׌ڌʔԑٙਪᕚdഅ٫ఱʔɓ

Իীሞf

150cਪᕚၾ޼Ӻcୋ61՜ୋ3ಂ

貳、安全研究中的個人態度：自我防衛的理論與假設

؄Ғ཭Samuel P. HuntingtonࠅࠠٙഹЪʘɓ{ࠏɛၾ਷࢕The

Soldier and The State1957{ᗵᔧə˰ɛ˸ֻ࿁ࠏ׵ɛ˸ʿࠏԫவࡈБุ

ٙႩٝf؄Ғ཭Ⴉމdࠏԫ݊ɓධਖ਼ุdה˸ଣሞɪՉ੽ุɛࡰᏐ຅̙˸ʔա

݊٫אط݁Չ˼ڢਖ਼ุ޴ᗫΪ९ٙᅂᚤdԸҁϓՉהረʚٙͦٙfމəࠏܵڭ

ɛ˸ʿࠏඟٙਖ਼ุd؄Ғ཭Ⴉމ˖ɛၾࠏɛᏐ༈ࠅਂϞٙࣖཞᕎdᜫࠏඟ̙˸

ዹͭط݁׵ʘ̮dɰʔึաՑ᜗Փ̮ٙ˖ɛהછՓdவɰఱ݊଺ɛ܄ٙٝהᝈ

˖ɛ୕ط฿ׂfீཀ༈ࣣٙሞࠑdܔͭəί຅˾ط݁ኪ˖ᘠʕ޼Ӻ˖؛ᗫڷ˸

ʿࠏඟၾ਷ٙ࢕ᗫٙڷՊᇍf

ఢਿί؄Ғ཭޼ٙӺʘɨdҢַࡁФ̈τΌ޼Ӻ຅ʕ఻ࡈᒔ͊׼ᆽઞ॰ٙ

ჯਹf࠯΋d؄Ғ཭ٙʱؓਉࠏ׵ࠠԫਖ਼ุɛࡰdतй݊ਖ਼ุ֜ࠏචᄴd࿁׵

ɓছɻж˸ʿڢᔖุࠏɛί዆ࠏࡈԫ᜗ӻʕהҲစٙԉЍdഹኈ༰ˇf್Ͼd

Іɚ኷˸ࠥdᎇഹ਷ყʘග਷ၾ਷ٙላ߉᎖ଟ˚နࠥЭd˸ʿ΢਷ɛɹٙҞ

஺ᄣ̋dɓছڢᔖุࠏɛʔ၍݊ί኷ఙ˸ʿ̻˚ࠏԫ৅ᇖʕٙԉЍே൳Ը൳ࠠ

ࠅfΪϤdə༆வԬಀ຾؂ҘཀٙҘӲ˸ʿܝ௪ࠏνО൙ᄆ˼ࡁա৅d˸ʿ݊

щΪމա৅הࣛପ͛ٙ࿒ܓᜊʷdආϾఱᜊϓڢ੬ࠅࠠfˈՉ݊࿁׵ԟԬ̙ঐ

ึቊաՉ˼਷ڧ࢕ଫٙ਷࢕ԸႭdִ݁ැ̀ࠅə༆؂Ҙ຾᜕࿁׵வԬɛٙҷ

ᜊdආϾһ̙˸Όٙ׌ࠦə༆ІԒࠏԫ৅ᇖٙᎴॹf

޼Ӻɓছࠏɛतйڢ݊ᔖุࠏɛ࿁ࠏ׵ඟ৅ᇖ˸ʿࠏඟٙ࿒ܓd࿁׵

ə༆˖؛ᗫٙڷᙄᕚɰϞᏍпfɽ௅ʱڢٙᔖุࠏɛί؂ҘҁʘܝఱึΫᓥ

ٟึd̙ঐɰึਗ਼˼ࡁίࠏԫ৅ᇖʕה੻Ցٙᄆ࠽ᝈd੭ආ͏ගٟึfˢৎࠏ

֜࿁ࠏ׵ඟٙ൙ᄆ˸ʿ࿒ܓdΫᓥٟึᜊϓ፯͏ٙৗͼࠏɛd࿁ࠏ׵ඟ͊Ըٙ

೯࢝dܼ̍ཫၑeᇜՓeޟЇ؛݊ኜᒅ൯dˢৎɓছɽ଺ேϞһٜટٙкᓙɢ

ձᅂᚤɢfࠏٙࠦࠋԫ຾᜕ܘϞ̙ঐึᜫவԬ፯͏ਗ਼Іʉٙ຾᜕ෂ༺ഗط݁ɛ

يdிϓ࿁ࠏඟٙᅂᚤdɰᅂᚤə˖؛ᗫڷf

ϾீཀவᅵٙҖόdҢࡁΝࣛගɰ̙˸ආɓӉַٙФd̘ܠϽவԬৗҘܝ

ࠏٙɛ/ҘӲdίࠦ࿁̙ঐٙ኷نላࣛ߉dνОҪІʉίա৅הࣛ੻Ցٙ຾᜕

ၾᝈชdҳ࢛Ց˼ࡁ࿁࢕ڭ׵ሊ਷ٙІҢԣሊจᗴɪfଭ௞˸ၽᝄرًٙԸ

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽᝄԣሊӔːc151

ႭdவԬৗҘٙҘӲਗ਼ϓމၽᝄࠏඟܝٙ௪Ҙࠏɛdίࠦ࿁኷ٙنක֐ʘࣛd

ᎇуึ஗ᅄ̜ɪ኷ఙၾᅮɛˢܳf݊Ϥdə༆ࠏɛա৅ٙࣛ຾᜕ၾᝈชdၾՉ

࿁׵ІҢԣሊӔːٙᅂᚤdྼ᙮τΌ޼Ӻ຅ʕڢ੬ٙࠅࠠᙄᕚf

ᄿ່ԸႭd͏จ࿁׵኷نၾІҢԣሊБਗٙ˕ܵึաՑ஢εΪ९ٙᅂᚤd

˴ࠅ̙˸ʱϓଣׂϽඎ˸ʿϓ͉ࣖूʱؓmaterial interestsՇɽᗳٙΪ९

Dill and Schubiger 2020fୋɓᗳٙΪ९݊᙮׵ଣׂɪٙdɛࡁึ൙ПԴ͜

؛ɢٙ̀׌ࠅe͍຅׌Էνj݊щୌΥ਷ყجd˸ʿණ᜗Бਗ݊щ࿁Іʉ

ה᙮໊ٙ᜗Ϟлfίࣔሊה᙮ૄ໊лूࡉࣛٙdɛࡁһ̙ঐึҳɝණ᜗Бਗ

Maher 2010; Koehler et al. 2016; Gelpi et al. 2006; Jentleson 1992; Jentleson and

Britton 1998fୋɚᗳٙΪ९݊ึϽඎՑࠏԫБމʔ၍݊ԣሊ٫אҸᏘ

̀඲ࠋࠅዄٙ˾ᄆdԷνϥෆɛᅰձڀ൬d˸ʿຑʾ݊٫א਷ყଡ଼ᔌ݊щɰ

˕ܵdɰఱ݊ႭdɛࡁึϽඎՑ኷ٙنϓ͉ࣖूMueller 1973; Flores-Macıas

and Kreps 2017; Kull 1995; Sobel 1997; Gelpi 2010; Grieco et al. 2011f

኷نБމଘऒՑٙΪ९޴຅ልᕏd͏଺̻੬ঐ੄ટᙃՑٙৃࢹɰʔεd

ጳሳஷ੬ɰ޴຅ϞࠢdΪϤίࠦ࿁΢၇ልᕏΪ९ࡉࣛٙdึԱቦत֛ٙઠܠ

heuristicsԸᏍпਂ̈Ҟ஺ٙкᓙfҢࡁႩމd຅ɛࡁϞ̀ࠅҳɝࠏԫБਗ

ආБІҢԣሊࡉࣛٙdՉʕɓٙࠅࠠࡈઠܠఱࡈ݊ɛ຅жٙ຾᜕dΪމவ݊௰

ٜટၾࠏԫБ޴މᗫٙ຾᜕dϞп׵Ңࡁ̘кᓙɪࠑଣׂۨ˸ʿϓ͉ࣖूՇɽ

ᗳٙΪ९fᑘԷϾԊdErikson and Stoker2011޼ٙӺᜑͪdᅄжٙ຾᜕࿁

׵ҘӲᅂᚤଉჃϾڗɮf˼ࡁʱؓəߕ਷൳኷ಂගٙᅄж຾᜕d޼Ӻ೯ତdί

ᅄжᆀீ຅ʕᐏ੻༰Э໮ᇁeɰఱ݊ᅄжනЗฏٙࠦۃɛdՉط݁࿒ܓึΪϤ

ᜊ੻һˀ኷eᄆ࠽ᝈׂึᜊ੻һІ͟ݼd˸ʿҳୃහΣһ਋Σ͏˴ᙣfɰఱ݊

Ⴍdࡈɛٙᅄжٙ຾ዝٙᆽܘ̙݊ঐึٜટᅂᚤՑɛࡁνОܙ޶኷نБމ˸ʿ

Չ˼ط݁ٙ՟Σfί̤̮ɓ޼ࡈӺʕdCampbell and McCormack1957ˢ༰

؂Ҙɓϋܝၾ؂Ҙ֜ࠏࠏ٤ٙۃd݊щί؂੽ᛆ۾ၾ۾ᛆ˴່ڦ΃Շࡈ࿒ࠦܓ

ΣɪϞהᄣ̋dഐ؈̈˷ՇЗ޼Ӻ٫จࣘʘ̮dɓϋ؂ٙਕ຾᜕ᜑഹࠥЭəவ

ՇࠦࡈΣط݁ٙ࿒ܓfʔ၍வࡈᜊʷٙ˙ΣνОdᐼϾԊʘd΋޼ۃӺ೯ତ؂

Ҙ຾᜕ٙᆽ̙݊ঐᅂᚤࠏɛط݁ٙ࿒ܓf

್Ͼdͦމۃ˟ၽᝄɛ͏࿁׵ІҢԣሊ˕޼ٙܵӺ˸ʿ͏ሜᒔ͊ઞী਷ɛ

152cਪᕚၾ޼Ӻcୋ61՜ୋ3ಂ

຅жٙ຾᜕ၾ኷ن˕޴ٙܵᗫ׌ၾΪ׌؈f݊Ϥd͉˖༊ྡ̘ܔ࿴வɓ˴ᕚٙ

޼ӺଣሞၾՉ޴࿁Ꮠٙ৿ணfҢࡁႩމdϞɧࡈΪ९࿁׵ઞীࡈɛٙ຅ж຾᜕

νО̙˸ၾϤɛ݊щ˕ܵ኷نආБஹഐतйࠅࠠÑ࿁׵຅ж຾᜕ٙ൙ᄆe݊щ

ႩΝණ᜗Бਗतй֜ڗ݊ჯኬd˸ʿ؂Ҙٙж၇f

࠯΋dҘӲί؂Ҙಂග࿁׵຅ж຾᜕ٙ˴ᝈ൙ᄆdึٜટᅂᚤ༈ҘӲ݊щ

ึ˕ܵՇ֦ක኷ࠏٙࣛԫБਗfί؂Ҙٙཀ೻dӊɓЗҘӲேટաəᅰࡈ˜ޟ

Ї݊ᅰϋࠏٙԫ৅ᇖfν؈வԬ຾᜕dίҘӲٙ˴ᝈႩ֛ɪdԨʔՈϞ΂Оٙ

ྼሯࣖɢd݊אҘӲί຅жܝкᓙவᅵٙ৅ᇖԨʔԑ˸תҤɛ͏༆הࠏ׳೯ৎ

̨ٙऎ኷نfίவᅵرًٙɨd݊߰੽ϓ͉ࣖूʱٙؓᝈᓃԸ޶dவԬҘӲІ

್ήఱึ࿁׵ၽऎʘග೯͛኷݊ࣛنщࠅ˕ࠏܵԫБਗdࠥЭ˼ٙࡁ˕ܵfଭ

௞dν؈ʊ຾Ⴉ֛əҳɝࠏԫБਗɰӚϞпת׵Ҥ༆ࠏ׳dԟІ್ఱʔึ˕ܵ

வᅵٙ፯ධf޴ˀٙdν؈வԬҘӲί؂Ҙʘܝd࿁׵຅жٙ຾᜕੭Ϟ͍Σٙ

˴ᝈкᓙdႩމவᅵࠏٙԫ৅ᇖཀ೻̙˸ᄣ̋ၽᝄɛ͏תҤʕ਷ڧଫٙঐɢၾ

ӔːdޟЇ݊Ϟࣖ౤ʺί኷ఙɪڌٙତၾ๟௪dۆҢࡁఱ̙˸ཫಂdவԬɛึ

һහΣ׵̘˕ܵ˸ࠏԫБਗΫᏐ̮Ըڧଫf࿁׵வԬɛϾԊdҳɝһεࠏԫɪ

ٙɛɢձيɢdே̙݊˸੻ՑΫజٙf࣬ኽ˸ɪীሞdҢٙࡁୋɓࡈ৿ண݊j

৿ணɓj ν؈ҘӲί؂Ҙʘܝd˴ᝈႩމ຅ж຾᜕͍݊ΣٙeϞᏍп

ٙdۆவԬҘӲఱึһ˕ܵІҢԣሊf

ୋɚdৰə࿁ࠏ׵ԫ৅ᇖج޶ٙʘ̮dɛ͏˕ܵԴ͜؛ɢၾщdܘɽ೻ܓ

ɪ݊՟Ӕ׵໊᜗ႩΝe˸ʿ࿁׵ණ᜗БਗٙชٝKoehler et al. 2016dतй

݊ၾɪॴ޴ٙஈf͟ࠏ׵ඟ຅ʕ௰੶ሜܛߏٙʘɓ؂݊੽dतй݊Ъ኷ࣛٙ

ࡉdה˸؂੽ɪॴܸٙͪԸੂБ΂ਕeආБ኷৸dࠏ݊ԫ৅ᇖϓ̌ʔ̙אॹٙ

௅ʱf್Ͼdӊࡈɪॴၾɨ᙮޴ٙஈேʔး޴Νdٙ֜ڗซجၾ৅ᇖ˙όٙʔ

ΝdேึᅂᚤՑՉၾɨ᙮ٙᗫڷfཀ̘ʊϞ஢ε޼Ӻܸ̈dٙ֜ڗჯኬࣸࠬึ

ᅂᚤଡ଼ᔌ˖ʷ˸ʿίᐄɻ֜жٙႩΝชeवᐄจᗴ˸ʿʈЪတจܓഃࠦΣԷ

νjᄎኮ׼e௓қ׼ 2018iҽֱ》 2019dΪϤҢࡁႩމdίࠏʕࡉࣛٙd

ν؈ၾɪॴ֜ڗʝਗٙ຾᜕͍݊ٙࠦdԟჿ؂жҘ٫һ׸࢙ʺৎ࿁ࠏඟٙႩΝ

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽᝄԣሊӔːc153

ชdชՑІʉࠏ݊ඟٙɓ΅ɿdԟჿɛࡁһϞ̙ঐึ˕ࠏܵඟٙБਗf8 Ңࡁ

ٙୋɚࡈ৿ண݊j

৿ணɚj ν؈ҘӲί؂Ҙࣛd˴ᝈႩމձɪॴ֜ڗܼ̍༟ଉא֜ࠏ

ɻ֜޴ஈٙ຾᜕͍֢݊ࠦεdۆฏϞ̙ঐ˕ࠏܵԫБਗf

ୋɧdʔΝࠏ၇ٙ຾᜕˸ʿ৅ᇖཀ೻dɰึᅂᚤՑɛٙࡁкᓙfၽᝄࠏٙ

၇ৣໄd˴ࠅܼ̍௔ࠏeऎࠏeࠏ٤ഃɧࠏd˸ʿՉ˼ɓԬЀᆞঐ༉ٙж߅྅

݊ኮжၾऎࠏ௔኷ඟdவԬʔΝࠏٙ၇ʿжࠋߠ߅ഹʔΝٙᔖᛆၾப΂fཀ̘

஢ε޼Ӻܸ̈௓ۊӱeඡወറ 2010; ௓ۊӱ 2016; ௓֚׹ 2016dɧ֜ٙࠏ

ɻж࿁ݔ׵Ԭᄆ࠽ᝈׂԷνࡐଣᝈׂeʈЪᄆ࠽ᝈึ̈ତᜑഹࢨٙମdԷ

ν௓ۊӱၾඡወറ2010೯ତdʔΝࠏ၇ʘ਷֜ࠏࠏdՉ࿁ᄆ࠽ᝈࠠٙൖ

೻ܓึϞᜑഹࢨମdவ݊͟׵΢ࠏ၇ேɓ֛ٙत׌ၾ˖ʷd΢הࣧࠏ੶ሜٙᄆ

࠽ᝈׂɰʔɓᅵfᄎ΀ॉeᖯอጳၾࢱ˝ᚆ2000һ೯ତdʔΝࠏ၇ࠏٙ

ɻ֜࿁ࡐଣᄆ࠽ᝈׂႩٝԨʔ޴Νfɰఱ݊ႭdʔΝࠏ၇ʘගٙ੃৅ቮϓ˙

όdึிϓ΢ࠏ၇ʘගᄆ࠽ᝈࢨׂٙମfʔཀdவԬᝈׂึνОᅂᚤՑ኷ٙن

˕ܵdͦ֠ۃ͊Ϟɓࡈଣሞ̙˸ΥଣཫПfҢ࣬ࡁኽ΋޼ٙۃӺ຅ʕ೯ତdԸ

ІʔΝචॴࠏٙɻ֜࿁ࠏ׵ɛᔖபʿ݊щᗴจᙼޒւᘠԸڭሊ਷࢕வධᄆ࠽ɪ

ࠦึϞהʔΝ௓ۊӱ2016dШͦ֠ۃ͊Ϟ০࿁ࠏ၇ࢨମٙሜݟdΪϤҢ

ࡁ˸ઞ॰όٙ˙όdԸীሞʔΝࠏ၇࿁׵ІҢԣሊจᗴٙᅂᚤf

ᒱ್݊˸ઞ॰ٙ˙όЪމ̈೯ᓃdШΪމӊɓࠏࡈ၇݊אޟж߅dேึΪ

މІʉίࠏԫላࠦהࣛ߉ᑗٙ΂ਕၾܿ኷dϾϞʔΝٙˀᏐf݊ϤdҢࡁႩ

މdί኷نʕ޴࿁ˢ༰ʔࠦ׸࢙࿁ࠦၾᅮɛ೵ж޴ટd݊א༈ࠏ၇ၾж߅ίᅰ

ඎ˸ʿҦஔɪࠦd༰ঐ࿁ᅮɛમ՟ˀՓٙЪ͜dவԬɛٙІҢԣሊ࿒ܓ̙ঐఱ

ึ༰৷dଭ௞˼ࡁ˴ᝈႩٙٝ኷ڀن൬ึ༰މʃfШЇ׵Ңࡁ˖ʕʱࠏٙؓ၇

8 வᗙႭٙɪॴܼ̍ɪॴ֜ࠏၾ༟ଉɻ֜ՇᗳdΪމӊࡈɛ຅жٙࣛචॴ

ʔΝdίʔΝ௅ඟɰึ༾ՑʔΝྼყ௰ϞᅂᚤɢٙɪॴdΪϤҢࡁί዁Ъʷ˙ࠦ

ԨӚϞतй֜ࠏ݊׼ܸᒔ݊ɻ֜f

154cਪᕚၾ޼Ӻcୋ61՜ୋ3ಂ

ၾж߅Ցࡳֵɓ၇ˢ༰̙˸တԑɪٙࠑૢ΁dவ௅ʱۆϞࠏ׵ܙԫ߅ኪٙਖ਼࢕

ၾኪ٫ί͊Ը౤Զһ༉းٙ໾̂fଭ௞ͦۃ͉˖ࠅ࠯ٙͦٙd̘݊೯ତவᅵ༨

ࠏ၇ࢨٙମ݊щπίf੽வࡈԉܓԸႭdҢٙࡁୋɧࡈ৿ண݊j

৿ணɧjʔΝࠏ၇ʘගd࿁׵኷ن˕ܓܵึՈϞᜑഹࢨମf

參、資料與研究設計

މəӻ୕ٙ׌ઞীၽᝄ͏଺຅ж຾᜕࿁׵኷ن࿒ٙܓᅂᚤd͉޼Ӻீཀ

ਪ՜ٙ˙όආБ༟ࣘϗණfί2018ϋ7˜6˚Ї7˜9˚dீཀط݁ɽኪ፯ᑘ

޼ӺʕːٙPollcracyLab˸ၣ༩ਪ՜ٙ˙όϗණə1001Зၽᝄ͏଺ٙจԈf

PollcracyLabٙᅵ͉Ը๕d݊ீཀط݁ɽኪ፯ᑘ޼Ӻʕːཀ̘ආБࠦஞၾཥ༑

ሜࣛݟd༔ਪᗴจ̋ɝၣ༩ሜٙݟ͏଺dԨίʘܝᑌᖩԨආБၣ༩ਪ՜ሜݟf

ΪϤd޴༰ၾՉ˼աஞ٫˴ਗਞၾopt-inٙਪ՜ሜݟԸႭd݁ɽٙ༟ࣘһ

ঐ੄൨ڐΌ਷˾׌ڌf࣬ኽ༈݁ɽ፯޼ʕː޼Ӻࣈںࡰശ2013޼ٙӺd

ίˢ࿁Ό਷˾ٙ׌ڌᅵ͉ഐ࿴ʘܝdவࡈ༟הࢫࣘႎණՑٙ༟ࣘdί60๋˸ɨ

ٙၽᝄ͏଺ʕ݊ՈϞΌ਷˾ٙ׌ڌf

዆΅޼Ӻਪ՜ί͍όੂБۃʊ຾ί2018ϋ6˜ҁϓཫ΋ൗ̅pre-

registrationd9 ᆽڭੂБཀ೻ၾܝᚃ༟ࣘஈଣʕӚϞኪஔࡐଣਪᕚf̤̮d

ί2018ϋ4˜ٙਪ՜ணٙࠇཀ೻ʕd޼Ӻ٫ʊ΋ਗ਼ਪ՜ণᇃഗ6Зၽᝄ͏଺ආ

Бଉܓஞሔin-depth interviewdࠅӋவ6З͏଺ਗ਼ਪ՜஼̩ਮཀdԨ݊׼ڌ

щଣ༆ਪ՜ٙจܠd˸ʿΫഈίᛘਪ՜ࣛːʕซՑʡჿഈࣩഃਪᕚd˸ᆽڭ

͏଺ᆽྼə༆዆΅ਪ՜f6З͏଺ߠٙ౻νڌ1d6З͏଺ேӚϞ˸ط݁ӻމ˴

ࡌe3ЗӲޫ׌ҘଭdШʔ݊қᗴҘdط݁ʿኪዝߠ౻εʩfଉܓஞሔഐ؈ᜑ

ͪਪ՜ٙʫ࢙݊6З͏଺ޫ̙Ό௅ə༆ٙdΪϤҢࡁႩމɓছၽᝄ͏଺ɰ̙˸

ᆽྼə༆Ԩ౛౥ਪ՜ʫ࢙f

9 ཫൗ̅ٙၣ१ஹഐਗ਼׵Ν኎ᄲݟᆽႩ̊೮ܝ౤Զfཫൗ̅ٙၣ१މOpen Science Frame-

workdၣѧމhttps://osf.iodൗ̅˚ಂމ2018ϋ6˜18˚f

τΌ޼Ӻࡈٙ᜗ʷjࡈɛ຅ж຾᜕νОᅂᚤၽᝄԣሊӔːc155

ڌ1cଉܓஞሔٙ͏଺ߠ౻

受訪者編號性別年齡學歷大學主修政治傾向從軍經驗

1 Ӳ 28ɽኪྡࣣ༟ৃ عၠ Ϟ

2 Ӳ 35ɽኪ ܛج ೌ Ϟ

3 Ӳ 41၂ɻཥዚʈ೻ عၠ Ϟ

4 ɾ 24ɚਖ਼ ึࠇع ᔝ ೌ

5 ɾ 31၂ɻيଣطᐕ عၠ ೌ

6 ɾ 58௹ɻ༟ৃʈ೻ عᔝ ೌ

աஞ٫ί෬ഈਪ՜ࣛdਪ՜ᕚͦމ፯͏จԈၾط݁ਞၾሜݟfᕚͦ΍

Ϟ40ᕚdίΌ௅ҁϓܝաஞ٫̙˸ᐏ੻100ʩکٙлਠֳᓃᅰ̔fਪ՜ۃ̒௅

݊Ϟᗫ׵͏଺ط݁ጳሳe݁ᙣႩΝe˸ʿ࿁׵ɘɚ΍ᗆ޴ٙج޶ᗫᕚͦdܝ̒

௅݊ۆၾ኷ن˸ʿ຅ж຾᜕޴ᗫٙᕚͦf

͉˖˴ٙࠅԱᜊᅰމୋ24ᕚdሗਪν؈˸ཧՑɤdɤڢ݊੬ᗴจdཧ݊

ڢ੬ʔᗴจdሗਪઆᗴʔᗴจ੽ࠏdאમ՟БਗתҤʕ਷ڧٙଫk10

...

The war in Ukraine is influencing how Taiwanese think about conflict

Summary

Full Text